• On BNET: 7 tips to speed up a PC
advertisement
October 27, 2008 12:00 AM PDT

iPhone 3G Nearly Unlocked, but Does It Matter?

Posted by Ben Wilson

The original iPhone was released with limited availability; the iPhone 3G was released with a wide distribution that has expanded since the rollout. The iPhone 3G can now be bought from a sanctioned carrier in most major world markets.

Given the device's broad availability, are baseband unlocks still important? The iphone-Dev Team seems to think so, having recently announced via video that the crack of the iPhone 3G baseband is close.

In the U.S., the iPhone 3G is tied to AT&T's network. According to activation terms you have to return your iPhone 3G within a certain period of time to get out of your two year contract. That's hardly an opportunity for you to buy, crack and start using your iPhone 3G on T-Mobile's network in the U.S. As such, the viability of hardware unlocks is mitigated.

In addition, the iPhone 3G is being legally sold as an unlocked device by 3 Hutchnison Telecommunications in Hong Kong and TIM in Italy. This means that users can insert any carrier?s SIM card into the device and access the attached network. However, both carriers are still requiring users to sign a two-year contract before they purchase the unlocked iPhones.

Of course, an iPhone 3G that can readily accept SIM cards from various international carriers, and does not have to be purchased in Hong Kong or Italy would be a boon for world travelers. As such, we'll be watching the iPhone Dev Team's progress closely.

Feedback? http://www.iphoneatlas.com/contact .

Recent posts from iPhone Atlas
Hoover's lays out mobile apps for business pros
AT&T Testing Enhanced Faster 3G
WebEx comes to the iPhone
Pandora 2.0 for iPhone released
Apple activates iTunes downloads over 3G, with a caveat
Macworld Keynote: iPhone Highlights
AT&T 3G Upgrades Reportedly Degrade EDGE Service
Best Buy offers refurbished iPhones
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 9 comments
by Eddy_K October 27, 2008 10:19 AM PDT
"In addition, the iPhone 3G is being legally sold as an unlocked device by 3 Hutchnison Telecommunications in Hong Kong and TIM in Italy." and in Belgium.
Reply to this comment
by ebernet October 27, 2008 2:29 PM PDT
Yeah, but what I want is when I go visit my brother in England, with a FULLY LEGIT iPhone that I only use on AT&T in the states, I can borrow his extra SIM card while I am there and not pay exorbitant fees. That was why I unlocked my 1st gen phone (although I also jailbroke that one). This time I don't need nor want Jailbreak, all I want is to be able to swap a SIM card in when I take a trip abroad (on the other hand, if AT&T just had a deal with a carrier in each contry to allow service at THEIR rates that would also work....)
Reply to this comment
by cnet.aaron October 27, 2008 2:43 PM PDT
That's actually not 100% true. Unlocked HK iPhones can be purchased without any contract whatsoever directly from the Apple store. Just walk in and buy one...
http://store.apple.com/hk/browse/home/shop_iphone/family/iphone?mco=MTE2NTQ
Reply to this comment
by cnet.aaron October 27, 2008 2:45 PM PDT
Also of note...the real question of value comes down to the radio bands that become available after the phone is unlocked. According to members of the Dev Team, T-Mobile's 1700Mhz band will not be usable (as 1700Mhz is not supported by the Infineon chip) and thus 3G connectivity will not be possible. I'm not sure if the same is true for the Verizon network.
Reply to this comment
by obsidi4n October 27, 2008 3:48 PM PDT
?In addition, the iPhone 3G is being legally sold as an unlocked device by 3 Hutchnison Telecommunications in Hong Kong and TIM in Italy.... However, both carriers are still requiring users to sign a two-year contract before they purchase the unlocked iPhones."

This is partly correct: in Italy the iPhone 3G is being sold by TIM and Vodafone. On top of that, you can choose to buy the phone with a 2 year contract or buy it separately for 499 ? (8Gb) and 569 ? (16Gb). In my case, I bought it from Vodafone and put on my 3 Hutchinson Italy sim card, they got way better data plans.
Reply to this comment
by dmjossel October 27, 2008 6:59 PM PDT
Does it matter?

YES.

Unlocks are about consumer choice, not about availability.
Reply to this comment
by gobberwart October 27, 2008 8:44 PM PDT
I agree with ebernet/dmjossel: I don't understand why the ability of a US iphone owner to buy a local SIM card in a foreign country (thus saving hundreds or even thousands of dollars over the ludicrously expensive AT&T romaing charges) is so under-valued in 3G unlock discussions. It's the single reason I haven't yet purchased iphones for my family: they'd be useless whenever we travel abroad. If and when the dev team find a 3G unlock mechanism I'll be cheering them and buying two 3G iphones.
Reply to this comment
by FraudFighterPro October 28, 2008 5:43 AM PDT
@cnet.arron

Verizon doesn't have a GSM network, so the iPhone will never work on Verizon - unless is supports CDMA.

As for unlocking. If AT&T would just hike the penalties of cancellation, then the only valid reason to unlock would be for use on an overseas carrier. With an unlock option, people will buy the phone at the subsidized price then cancel service and pay the term fee. Make the term fee equal to 2 years of service costs at $70 per month and AT&T then would not care who unlocked.

I want the unlock too - visiting UK means I pay $1.29 per minute unless I pay $5.99 per month to lower my rate to $0.99. I can buy a SIM that costs me only $0.10 for calling within UK and back to the US.

The catch on the AT&T World Traveler $5.99 plan is that they tell you to keep in for 3 months to make sure all your usage is accounted for at the lower rate. So even if you are overseas for 2 days, you need to spend $18 to make sure you are billed at the lower rate. I would have to use 60 minutes to break even.

If the EU carriers can charge $0.10 per minute for calls to the US, then AT&T could do something similar when we are over there. They will just lose revenue by forcing us down an unlock path, rather then by having decent International roaming rates.
Reply to this comment
by oliverhart77 November 2, 2008 11:53 AM PST
@ fraud fighter pro-

Verizon does have GSM funtionality, just not in the US. If you have a supported device (blackberry world edition) it comes with a sim card and can be only used abroad. Verizon is owned by vodafone so when out of the states you just pop in the sim and go. The verizon sim will work in an iPhone, just not in the US
Reply to this comment
advertisement

About iPhone Atlas

iPhone Atlas helps you navigate the ins-and-outs of Apple iPhone ownership with how-tos, troubleshooting information, news, reivews, and more.

Add this feed to your online news reader

iPhone Atlas topics