Existing users, log in.  New users, create a free account.  Lost password?

iPhones, in some situations, can’t take incoming calls while on EDGE

Posted 27 July 2007 @ 9am in Troubleshooting

We previously noted that the iPhone may miss calls while sleeping (locked). Some users are now reporting what seems to be a significant issue where their iPhones cannot receive incoming calls while transferring EDGE data. Here, in a nutshell, is what appears to be happening:

The iPhone cannot simultaneously use EDGE and voice services. That is, if you are on a call, you cannot concurrently access EDGE-data functions. In addition, as documented in Knowledge Base article #305711:

“While iPhone is actively transferring data over EDGE—downloading a webpage, for example—you may not be able to receive calls. Incoming calls may go to voicemail.”

The “may not be able to receive calls” portion stems from the fact that there are two types of EDGE network types, NOM1 and NOM2. When your iPhone is connected to a NOM1 network, the data transmission will generally be interrupted, and the incoming call allowed to come through. When your iPhone is connected to a NOM2 network, however, the EDGE data transfer process cannot be interrupted, and the call will generally go to voicemail.

Fortunately, there is a way to check whether you are connected to a NOM1 or NOM2 network. First, put your iPhone in field test mode by accessing the Phone application, tapping Keypad, then entering *3001#12345#* and pressing Call.

Tap GPRS Information and look at the entry next to nom. It will be either 1 or 2. If you see a 1, you’ll likely be able to receive a call while transferring data. If you see a 2, you likely won’t.

Unfortunately, it appears that NOM2 is much more prevalent on AT&T’s data network. In fact, we’ve yet to see our iPhone connect to a NOM1 network. As such, we can’t even state with certainty that the iPhone supports NOM1 at all.

Here’s a more detailed description contained in a patent application for “Limiting services based on location.”

“GPRS network 130 can be designed to operate in three network operation modes (NOM1, NOM2 and NOM3). A network operation modes of a GPRS network is indicated by a parameter in system information messages transmitted within a cell. The system information messages dictates a MS where to listen for paging messages and how signal towards the network. The network operation mode represents the capabilities of the GPRS network. In a NOM1 network, a MS can receive pages from a circuit switched domain (voice call) when engaged in a data call. The MS can suspend the data call or take both simultaneously, depending on the ability of the MS, In a NOM2 network, a MS may not received pages from a circuit switched domain when engaged in a data call, since the MS is receiving data and is not listening to a paging channel In a NOM3 network, a MS can monitor pages for a circuit switched network while received data and vise versa. ”

Feedback? info@iphoneatlas.com.

[ Digg this  |  Bookmark on del.icio.us ]

Print This Post Print This Post

5 Comments

Posted by fhdogs
27 July 2007 @ 11am

This has been a long running issue with the EDGE network. Thus the reason when I purchased a my first smartphone (Treo 650) I opted to get it through sprint. I’d love an iPhone, but when I get phone calls they are urgent. Everything else is email. So what’s more important, the common email or an urgent call that ends up in voicemail. I think the network is backwards.

Posted by luomat
27 July 2007 @ 3pm

fhdogs- having had a Treo 650 on Sprint’s network for 18 months I can personally attest that it too has the exact same problem on its network.

If the data connection is actively downloading something on Sprint calls will go to voicemail

Yes they have their priorities messed up but Sprint is no better.

Posted by fjoemako3
29 July 2007 @ 12am

Another limitation of using the EDGE network is that you are unable to see attachments on emails viewed in the mail app. You must be on wi-fi to even see if there is an attachment on a newly recieved email. It also leaves no hint that attachments were removed.

Posted by scotty321
30 July 2007 @ 1pm

This is the same thing with my Treo 650 on the Sprint network. It’s just something you get used to.

Posted by vernonintx
1 August 2007 @ 10pm

To fjoemako3 - Yes, it will download the attachments, but since it is an edge network, you have to have patience to load it. Someone just sent me a 400k pdf file. It took it about 4-7 minutes to load, but it did load. I then clicked on it and viewed the pdf. I don’t think that the iphone actually downloads the messages until you read them. It just gets the header info and then downloads the attachment when you click on it.

You must log in or register to post a comment.